Legal Implications:
- Maximum Penalty:
- For an indictable charge, the maximum penalty can be as high as 10 years in prison, signifying the seriousness of the offence.
- Variety of Actions Constituting Harassment:
- Harassment charges can stem from activities such as stalking, repeated communications, watching or besetting a dwelling-house, or any generally threatening conduct directed towards an individual over time.
Essential Element: Reasonable Fear
- Defining Reasonable Fear:
- The prosecution must establish, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the person being harassed had reasonable fear for their safety or the safety of anyone known to them. This fear can be induced by persistent unwanted communications, stalking, or threatening behavior over time.
- Gray Areas and Defensibility:
- Defending against a harassment charge often involves navigating gray areas where the line between persistent communication and criminal harassment is blurred. Success in these cases often depends on the credibility and reliability of the accused compared to the alleged victim.
Legal Strategy and Possible Outcomes:
- Case-Specific Assessment:
- An experienced criminal lawyer assesses the conduct in question in light of established case law to determine the defensibility of the charge. Then strategic decision making and a cost-benefit analysis is conducted to compare the odds of winning a particular case at trial, versus the best possible negotiated resolution.
- Negotiation and Outcomes:
- Depending on the severity of the harassment, negotiations may lead to positive outcomes such as a conditional discharge, a peace bond coupled with a withdrawal of the charge, or a straight withdrawal or, in more serious cases, short jail terms.
Similar Offence: Repeated Phone Calls with Harassment Intent
- Analogous Offence:
- The Criminal Code includes a separate charge related to repeated phone calls for harassment purposes. While similar to criminal harassment, it has distinct penalties. The maximum jail term if the Crown elects by indictment is 2 years.
Range of Outcomes:
- Defendable Cases:
- Defendable cases may result in avoiding a criminal record, conditional discharges, or a negotiated peace bonds coupled with a withdrawal of the charge, or a straight withdrawal, for less severe offences.
- Serious Consequences:
- In cases of significant stalking and harassment causing substantial fear, an accused may face short, mid-range or longer jail terms depending on the severity of the conduct. The possibility of significant jail terms emphasizes the gravity with which the legal system views such offences.



