Key Considerations
- Consent and Injury:
- No Bodily Harm: If the physical altercation does not result in bodily harm, this may be considered a defence. The landmark case of R. v. Jobidon establishes that mutual fights without bodily harm should not result in a criminal conviction.
- Bodily Harm Definition: Bodily harm, as per the Criminal Code, is broadly defined and can include even minor injuries such as bruises. If bodily harm occurs, the mutual agreement does not serve as a defence.
- Defending the Charge:
- Self-Defence: In cases involving bodily harm, the primary defence is creating a reasonable doubt that the actions were in self-defence. If the accused can demonstrate a genuine need to protect themselves, it may impact the outcome.
- Legal Complexity:
- No Cancellation of Assaults: It’s crucial to understand that if one person is charged with assault in a mutual fight, it does preclude the other person from also being charged.
- Each party may face charges independently, and the mutual nature of the altercation does not nullify the legal consequences if bodily harm was caused.