Key Points
-
Under-Oath Video Statements:
- Victims provide under-oath video statements (KGB statements) to the police regarding the alleged assault.
-
Recantation Attempts:
- Weeks later, victims may want to reconcile with the accused and recant their statements, claiming they were intoxicated and don’t remember the details.
-
Challenges for the Accused:
- Accused individuals often wonder why charges are not dropped when the victim wants to recant.
-
Crown’s Perspective:
- The Crown is cautious and skeptical about recantations, as statistics show that some victims may not be truthful in their recanted statements.
-
Policy and Directives:
- Over the years, policies and directives have been established, making it rare for the Crown to drop charges solely based on a recanted statement.
-
Concerns About Safety:
- The Crown is concerned that withdrawing a domestic assault charge based on the complainant recanting their statement, and allowing the accused to go home may result in further harm to the victim, considering the potential risks of repeated abuse.
-
Decision to Proceed to Trial:
- In many cases, the Crown decides to proceed to trial, setting a date a year down the road, allowing the truth to emerge during testimony.
-
Cross-Examination Strategies:
- During trial, the Crown may confront the recanting victim with their previous under-oath statement to establish inconsistencies.
-
Unsatisfactory Outcome:
- While these laws aim to protect potential victims, innocent individuals may find the process unsatisfactory as they navigate through the legal system.
-
Potential Case Outcomes:
- The case may go to trial, leading to a possible acquittal if a reasonable doubt is established. In some cases, the Crown might withdraw the charge or opt for a peace bond if there is no reasonable chance of conviction.
-
Communication with Clients:
- Defence lawyers must communicate these complexities to clients early in the case, helping them understand the legal process and potential outcomes.



